“ Still the best pizza! I grew up in Manville, believing Manville Pizza was the best. I have never found better pizza. I recently visited for a High School reunion and met some friends at Manville Pizza. Where else are you going to go? It's just as good as it ever was. The staff is still the best around. We tried several pies and there was no favorite. All were excellent. ”

“ I grew up on manville pizza. Since I could walk this has been shoved down my throat and I'm beyond happy I did Never did I realize how great this is or appreciate it until I moved to PA. I've had every single type of pizza on that menu. The classic plain slices are so thick and sauce is to die for The chicken bacon ranch is awesome. My sister gets it at least once a month no matter what Me personally, the best specialty slice is the Fra Diavlo. PACKED with a spice flavor in that sauce and loaded with chicken It's a shame the father passed away. He was such a nice old little Italian man. The son is okay. I've caught him ringing things up I didn't order before and make different prices on slices before.... The pizza is great, the service has gone down so that's why I'm not giving it 5 stars ”

“ Manville Pizza is, hands down, one of the best pizza spots I've ever had the pleasure of discovering. Hands down the best pizza. Every pie I've tried is a perfect balance of textures and flavors. The crust is just the right thickness, with a light crispness on the outside giving way to a wonderfully chewy interior. Their sauces are rich and bursting with fresh tomato flavor, and the cheese melts into every slice like pure silk. And let's talk about the wings: they are absolutely phenomenal. Tender on the inside and perfectly crispy on the outside, these wings pack incredible flavor in every bite. Whether you prefer them mild, hot, or our favorite hot honey garlic, they strike the perfect balance and pair perfectly with any pizza order. It's clear that the same dedication to quality that shines through in their pizza also extends to these savory, satisfying wings. Those hot honey garlic wings are so dangerously addictive, it's as if someone slipped a pinch of culinary contraband into the sauce, leaving you blissfully hooked with each sticky, spicy, and sweet bite. Best of all, our 3yo son absolutely adores their pizza--it's the only place he genuinely gets excited about. We never have to convince him to come out with us; he practically begs for their delicious, cheesy slices! ”

“ Truly astounding. I am very particular about my pizza. I have visited and ranked 59 pizza places in NJ and NY and this place immediately jumped to the top of the list. Yes, above that WAY more famous place in Raritan, not more than 5 minutes away. There are several reasons for this. 1. The pizza is outstanding. I tried three varieties. The square crispy cup pepperoni pizza (a slice) that had a wonderful crust and just the right of pepperoni that was perfectly crisp. Think of kind of a grandma's crust. Then the Sicilian (also a slice). I normally don't go for the Sicilian but when the owner, Anthony, found out I was there for the first time he insisted I try it on the house. He is, rightfully, quite proud of it. Very light and airy, thick crust with a focaccia-like middle and a nice crunchy crust. Good amount of cheese and sauce. I liked the pepperoni a bit better because that is more my style but this was exceptional as far as Sicilian goes. And now, the star of the show. The 'Skinny Vinnie'. I am a sucker for a thin pizza with a ring of caramelized cheese around edge and this did not disappoint. Very much like another highly rated place in Millburn. The bottom is well done (to the point some people complain about it) but you have to get a good scald on it in order to get the right crisp on the crust and the right singe on the cheese. It was dark brown but not at all burned. No bitterness at all. The sauce has a bit of sweetness but is balanced out with salt. The cheese is top notch. Just amazing pizza, top to bottom. 2. The owner. As I said, Anthony (son of the original owner, Vinnie) gave me a free slice of Sicilian because he was just dying for me to try it. Talked to him for a bit. Super nice guy. Also, I forgot to order the Skinny Vinnie and just asked for a plain pie and when I realized that 10 minutes later they happily made me a Skinny Vinnie without hassle. 3. You can get in there without standing in line for 20 minutes and they don't run out of pizza at 12:45. I really hope Mr. One Bite never comes to visit. He would give it a 9 and it would suddenly be overrun with people. That would be good for Anthony so maybe I don't wish it but selfishly, just for me, I'd rather have easier access. Either way, it is a secret that shouldn't remain a secret. So, just brilliant all the way around. Can't say enough nice things about it. This review is five times longer than most of mine but it is just that good. I'm just upset it took me this long to get here. Had to wade through 58 other pizzas and finally found what I was looking for all along. ”

“ Such friendly staff great service- he even gave us a taste of grandma's pizza as we were tossing between that and pizza primavera . Grandma's pie has a slight garlic flavor and was fresh tomatoes, sauce, and cheese with a thin crust yet very filling. Pizza Primavera was delicious with fresh broccoli and tomatoes adorned with a ton of cheese and had a thicker crispy crisp. Definitely a place to try. Can't wait to eat leftovers plus owner says it freezes welll it's a double win we wil definitely be back ”

“ This place is on point! I ordered a Sicilian pie cooked just the way it should be, and they also ask if you want it well done. I'll definitely be back soon. ”

“ ALWAYS an A-mazing pie!! I've been ordering from Manville for years now and they have never disappointed me. I love so many of their pies (ex. The Works, Pepperoni, Sausage & Broccoli Rabe), their Stromboli is the way you should expect a quality Stromboli, Chicken Roll can't be beat, Calzones are packed with fillings & the creamiest Ricotta you could ever ask for.... Which leads us to the photos below. This is their Eggplant Rollatini Pie. Fried eggplant, their incredibly simple yet perfect sauce, quality mozzarella & truly the purest, creamiest & slightly sinful Ricotta you have ever tasted! Their dough is light yet holds up to any toppings you add and the crust is always the cherry on the meal... perfect texture, chew & crisp. Don't sleep on Manville!! ”

“ As usual, the best pizza in the area. Manville Pizza has been a family favorite since we moved to Hillsborough and we've now been ordering pizza here for nearly 16 years. Between the pies and the counter slices, you really can't go wrong. They have the best sauce in the area. It's not too sweet, but also not too acidic. Every time that I have had pizza elsewhere, I can never find a crust that compares to Manville Pizza. The crust is soft and chewy with the perfect crisp. Everywhere else is either too doughy, or way too hard. Here, it's perfect. Some must try items are the chicken vodka pizza, hot honey with pepperoni, sweet Vanessa, and definitely try their Italian sub and cheesesteak. So many great choices that you can't go wrong! ”

“ This was the second time I had ordered takeout from this location. The pizzas are pretty amazing and the staff is super friendly, very casual dining place. Prices are pretty decent and comparable to most pizzerias. We decided to try the skinny Vinny pizza this time around and I must say it was delicious. I ordered it with pepperoni and onion. The crust was thin and buttery and full of flavor. You can get whatever toppings you want but don't go overboard as you don't want to take away from the crispy crust. Try those zeppolis they are delicious!! ”